---
Title: Excerpts for the «Dialectics of Nature» (I). Thomson and Tait, «Treatise on Natural Philosophy», 3
Description: Third part of Engels's excerpts from Thomson and Tait: friction, attraction and potential, statics of solids and fluids, elasticity, tides, precession and rigidity of the earth, and W. Thomson's paper on the secular cooling of the earth; with comments in German.
Author: Friedrich Engels
Date: 1877
URL: https://marxismo.school/archivo/marx-engels/originales/1877%20Excerpts%20for%20the%20Dialectics%20of%20Nature%20%28I%29.%20Thomson%20and%20Tait%2C%20Treatise%20on%20Natural%20Philosophy%2C%203
---


*Excerpts by Friedrich Engels, undated (the MEGA² dates the notebook between mid-1877 and early 1883), kept at the IISG (Karl Marx / Friedrich Engels Papers, inv. J 42, «Heft XVI», images 13-18: five pages in two columns and the first column of image 18), transcribed from the digital facsimile by the Escuela de marxismo, 2026 (two independent readings, collation with the image and, for doubtful passages, with the extracts of the MEGA² IV/31 text available through the De Gruyter search engine; only readings confirmed by the image were adopted). Third and last part of the Thomson and Tait excerpts (continuing parts 1 and 2) of the notebook that the MEGA² (IV/31) records as excerpts from works by William Thomson, Peter Guthrie Tait, Carl Fraas, Hermann Helmholtz and Jean Baptiste Le Rond d'Alembert; the further parts appear separately (the Wiedemann excerpts are not in this notebook). Excerpted from: W. Thomson and P. G. Tait, Treatise on Natural Philosophy, vol. I, Oxford 1867 (see part 1), with W. Thomson's paper on the secular cooling of the earth. Engels copies passages in English and summarises or comments in German (German script); his own remarks, exclamation marks and parenthetical glosses are in German. Diplomatic transcription, line by line, with the abbreviations of the manuscript; underlining in *italics*, deletions ~~thus~~, insertions {thus}; formulas on one line (^ = exponent, / = fraction); drawings are indicated as [figure: …]; Engels's sign for negation is given as [signo: …]. 67 of 4336 words (1,5 %) are marked as uncertain ([?]) or illegible; every line containing them has a note. [Traducción al español](https://marxismo.school/archivo/marx-engels/1877%20Extractos%20para%20la%20Dial%C3%A9ctica%20de%20la%20naturaleza%20%28I%29.%20Thomson%20y%20Tait,%20%C2%ABTratado%20de%20filosof%C3%ADa%20natural%C2%BB,%203)*
### Image 13, column 1

inkompressibl. & vollkomm. plastisch. Masse. Dann werd  
nach einand. die Correktion eingesetzt für Compressi-  
bilität, innerer Reibg v. Flüssigkt, die dadch erzeugte  
Wärme, deren ausdehnende[?] Wirkg &c, also kommen[^1]  
wir zu e. Resultat das innerhalb der Beobachtgs-feh-  
lergränze[?] m.[?] d. Erfahrg stimmt. 337-79[^2]  
There is *no* *Question* in physical science wh  
can be *completely* & *accurately* investigated by  
*mathl* reasoning, wohl aber verschiedne Grade dr  
approximat. & genügend 339.  
*Reibg* – Gesetze untersucht bes. dch Coulomb.  
To produce sliding of one solid body on another,  
the surfaces in contact being plane requires a  
tangential force wh depends 1) on the nature of  
the bodies 2) on their polish or the species & quan-  
tity of lubricant applied, 3) on the *normal pressure*  
between them to which it is generally {directly} propl, 4) on  
the length of time during wh they may have  
been ... in contact 340.  
*Statics of a particle*.  
For the equilibm of a particle it is *necessary*  
*& sufficient* that the algebraic sums of the ap-  
plied forces, resolved *in any 3 rectangular*  
*directns*, *shd vanish*. 342  
If the particle rest on a smooth curve, the  
resolved force along the curve must vanish.  
If the curve be rough, the resultant force  
along it must be balcd by frictn  
If the particle rest on a smooth surface, the  
resultant of the applied forces must be ppdicl  
to the surface.  
If the surface be rough, then frictn comes in, &  
if the force be gravity, & the deviatn of the surface  
from the normal be at angle ι, then the normal  
pressure on the surface is evidently W cos ι (W the  
weight of the particle) & the resolved part of the weight  
along the surface is W sin ι. Diesem muß die  
Reibg d. Gleichgewicht halten. An der Gränze wo das  
Partikel *aber noch* [signo: nicht] rutscht, wird d. ~~größte~~ Maximum  
d. statisch Reibg thätig, also (μ der Coeff. der stat. Reibg)  
W sin ι = μ W cos ι.  
also μ = tang ι.  
Der so gefundne Werth für ι ist der Ruhewinkel, angle

### Image 13, column 2

of repose (bei Sandhaufen, slopes of debris ~~[ilegible]~~  
& Felsen[?] &c. 343.44.[^3]  
Gesetz der Grav. das Attr wie d. Masse & umgek. wie  
die Qu. d. Entferng gilt für Schwere[?], El. Magn &[^4]  
wahrscheinl. für alle natürl. Fernwirkg  
Massen M & m bei Abstd D wirken auf einander  
wie Mm/D^2. 345.  
Ein Pkt *innerhalb* {(inwendig[?])!} e. Kugelfläche, der v. allen Pkt.[^5]  
dr Fläche nach obig. Gesetz angezog. wird, erleidet  
*keine Attraktion*. 346. Ein Pkt *außerhalb* dr Fläche  
wird so attrahirt, als wäre die ganze Masse im  
Mittelpkt dr Kugel konzentrirt.  
*Potential*. This function was introduced for gravity  
by Laplace, but the name was first given to it by  
Green who may almost be said to have created  
the theory as we now have it. Green's work was  
neglected till 1846, & before that time most  
of its important theorems had be rediscovd.  
by Gauss, Chasles, Sturm & Thomson.  
Bei allen Kräften die {*in e. konservativen System*} in die Ferne wirken (wirkl. oder  
scheinbar), it is most convenient (in general) to  
choose, for the zero configuration, infinite dis-  
tance between the bodies concerned. Also:  
The mutual potential energy of 2 bodies  
in any relative position is the amount of  
work obtainable from their mutual repulsion,  
by allowing them to separate to an infinite dis-  
tance asunder. When the bodies *attract* each  
other, (gravitatn alone acting, &c.[?]) their mutual[^6]  
*potential energy*, according to the convention  
for zero now adopted, is *negative*, or (see  
§ 547 below) *their exhaustion of potential energy*  
*is positive*  
The *Potential*, at any point, due to any  
attracting or repelling body, or distribution of matter,  
is the mutual potential energy between it & a  
unit of matter placed at that point; but in  
*the case of gravity*, to avoid defining the potential  
as a – quantity, it is convenient *to change*  
*the sign*. Thus the gravitatn potential, at  
any point, due to {any} mass, is the quantity  
of work required to remove a unit of matter  
from that point, to an infinite distance.  
Hence if V be the potentl. at any point  
P, & V, that at a proximate point Q, ...

### Image 14, column 1

V – V, is the work required to remove an independent  
unit of matter from P to Q; & ... this is altogether  
independent of the ~~path~~ form of the path chosen  
between these 2 points. 363.  
Suppose Q to be so near to P, that the attractive  
forces exerted on unit of matter at these points,  
& therefore at any point in the line PQ, may be  
assumed to be equal & parallel. Then, if F repre-  
sent the resolved part of this force along PQ,  
F. PQ is the amount of work required to trans-  
fer unit of matter from P to Q. Hence:  
V – V, = F × PQ; F = (V – V,)/PQ  
that is, the attraction on unit of matter at P in  
any direction PQ, is the rate at wh the potential  
at P increases per unit of length of PQ.  
(487.) A surface, at every point of wh the potentl.  
has the same value (equipotential surface) is  
such that the attraction is everywhere in the directn  
of its normal. For in no direction along the  
surface does the potl. change ~~its~~ value & therefore  
there is no force in any such directn. Hence if  
the attracted particle be placed on such a surface  
(supposed smooth & rigid) it will rest in any position  
on the surface, is therefore sometimes called a sur-  
face of Equilibrium. We shall see[?] later that[^7]  
the force on a particle of liquid at the free  
surface is always in the directn of the normal,  
hence the term *Level surface* (for the same)  
(488.) If a series of equipotl. surfaces be con-  
structed ~~at~~ for values of the potl. increasing  
by equal small amounts, it is evident from  
486 that the attractn at any point is inversely  
propl to the normal distance between 2 suc-  
cessive surfaces close to that point, since the  
numerator (in this case) of the expression for F  
is constant.  
489. A line drawn from any origin, so that  
at every point of its length its tangent is the  
direction of the attraction at that point, is  
called a *Line of Force*, & it obviously cuts at  
right angles every equipotentl. surface it meets. {364}  
491. In estimating work done against a force which  
varies inversely as the sq of {the} distance fm a fixed

### Image 14, column 2

point, the mean force is to be reckoned as the  
geometricl. mean betw the forces at the beginning  
& end of the path, & whatever may be the path  
followed, the *effective space* is to be reckoned  
as the *diffce of distances from the attracting point*.  
Thus the work done in any course is equal to the pro-  
duct of the distances diffce of the of the extremities  
from the attractive point into the geometrl. mean  
of the forces at these distances; or, if O be the  
attracting point & m its force on a unit mass at  
unit distance, the work done in movg a particle  
of unit mass from any position P to any other positn  
P' is  
(OP' – OP) √(m^2/(OP^2 . OP'^2)) = m/OP – m/OP'  
∴ hence it is obvious that the potentl. at P  
of a mass m situated {[ilegible]} at O, is m/OP. ~~& since~~[^8]  
~~suppose m^1 m^2 m^3 &c in P^1 P^2 P^3 &c = Σ m/OP.~~ 366.  
Die mutual potl. energy of 2 particles at  
distance D ist d. Prod. ihrer Massen dividirt dch die  
Entferng. (wenn d. Attr. propl dem umgekehrt. Quadr. dr  
Entferng). Bei vielen Part = Σ(m/D) 367  
The mean potl. over any spherical surface  
due to matter entirely *without* it, is equal to the potl.  
at its center (Gauss) 373.  
§ 394 Green[?] Behauptg[?] dß [signo: nicht] alle Kpr centrobaric;[^9]  
if the actn of gravity, terrestl or other, on a rigid  
body is reducible to a single force in a line always  
passing through ~~the same~~ {one} point, fixed relatively to the  
body, whatever be its positn relatively to the ... attracting  
mass, that point is Cd its C of gravity & the body  
*Centrobaric*; d. Kpr wirkt als ob alle s. Masse im  
Schwerpkt konzentrirt wäre. Der Schwerpkt. liegt  
nothwdg im Innern dr Kprs & kann nur dch Eindrg in {P}[?][^10]  
s. Masse erreicht werd. Daher e. Hohlkugel m.[?] e. Loch[^11]  
hat kein Schwerpkt, noch e. Ring od. hohl Cylind. m.[?] offn[^12]  
Endn. 395.96.  
Die Trägheitsmomente e. Centrobar. Kprs sind  
= um *alle* Axen dch d. Schwerpkt, d. Kpr also kinetisch-  
symmetrisch um diesen, 398.  
549. If two systems or distributions of matter,  
M & M', given in spaces, each finite, but infinitely  
far asunder, be allowed to approach one another,  
a certain amount of work is obtained by mutual  
gravitation; & their mutual potl. energy loses, or  
as we may say *suffers exhaustion* to this amount,  
wobei für die erreichtn Endstellg die durchlaufn Umwege

### Image 15, column 1

bewirkt. Hence if m1 m2 m3 .. be particles of M  
m1' m2' m3' .. of M'; v1' v2' .. the potl. due to M' at  
the points occupied by m1 m2 &c; v1, v2 .. those due  
to M at m1' m2' &c & E the exhaustion of  
mutl. potl. energy between the 2 systems in any  
configuratn – we have E = Σ m'v = Σ mv'  
bei Ext.[?] Dichtigkt ρ für M ρ' für M' – ρ a dis-[^13]  
continuous functn expressing the density at any  
point xyz of mass M & vanishing at any point  
not occupied by matter of this distributn – then  
E = ∫∫∫ ρv' dx dy dz = ∫∫∫ ρ'v dx dy dz  
the integrals being extended throughout all space.  
*Verdichtg*. Gesetzt 2 Partikel m1 & m2; die Erschöpfg  
dr pot. En. bei Annäherg v.[?] unendl.[?] Entferng zu Abstd D(1,2)[^14]  
= m1 m2/D(1,2); kommt noch e. dritter[?] m3, so die weitere Erschöpfg[^15]  
= m1 m3/D(1.3) + m2 m3/D(2,3); ganz[?] allg.[?] gegeben, die Gesammter-[^16]  
schöpfg E = ΣΣ mm'/D where m m' the masses  
of any 2 of the particles, D their distance & ΣΣ the  
sum of the expressions for all the pairs, each pair  
taken once. If v be the potl., at point occupied  
by m1, of *all the other masses*, the expressn becomes a  
simple sum with as many terms as masses,  
wh we may write thus: E = ½ Σ mv., ½, because  
Σ mv takes each pair m1 m2/D(1.2) twice over. If the  
particles form an ultimately continuous mass  
with density ρ at any point xyz .. we have  
E = ½ ∫∫∫ ρv dx dy dz as the expressn  
of the exhaustion of potl. energy of gravitatn ac-  
companying the condensatn of a quantity of matter  
from a state of infinite diffusion (where density  
is everywhere infly small) to its actual conditn  
in any finite body. 409.  
Ch. 7. *Statics of solids & fluids*.  
(557) I For equilibm of rigid body it is necessary that  
the algebr. sum of the components of all the forces  
acting on the body, in any directn whatever, shd vanish.  
It is sufficit. for this that the sum vanish in each  
of any 3 assumed directns not in one plane; for  
any translation may be resolved parallel to such  
lines. (Gewöhnl. rechtwinkl. gewählt) 412.

### Image 15, column 2

II. *About an axis*: for equilib of rig body, it is necess  
that the sum of the moments of the forces about *any*  
*axis whatever* shall vanish. Since a rotatn about  
*any* axis whatever is equivt. to translatns parallel  
to, & rotatns about, any 3 axes ([signo: not] in one plane)  
~~it is sufficit~~ passing through one point; it is sufficit.  
in additn to I, that the sums of the moments of  
the forces about any 3 *rectang* axes meeting in a  
point shd vanish.  
III When the forces are all in one plane, nur  
3 Bedinggn aus[?] obig 6:[^17]  
the sums of the components in any two (rectang)  
directns must separately vanish  
the sum of the moments about any axis  
*ppdicl* to the plane of the forces must vanish 413.  
(672) *A perfectly elastic body* is a body, wh, when  
brought to any one state of strain, requires at  
all times the same stress to hold it in this state,  
however long it be kept strained or however rapid  
ly its state be altered fm any other strain or  
fm no strain, to the strain in question. (Tempe-  
raturänderg ausgeschlossen – wenn diese[?] abr eingeschlossn[^18]  
insofern dß absolute Unveränderlkt dr Temp. bedungen,  
od. aber Rückkehr zur Ausgangstemp. nach Wechseln  
dr Strains, dann annähernd d. vollelast.[?] Kpr in[^19]  
dr Natur erfüllt ist; in Wirklkt erfüllt dch alle Flüssigktn  
& vielleicht Krystalle. But inasmuch as the elastic  
reaction of every kind of body against strain  
varies with varying temp. & (a thermodynamic  
conseq. of this as we shall see) any increase or  
diminution of strain in an elastic body  
is necessarily accompd by a change of temp.,  
even a pftly elastic body cd [signo: not], in passing thro  
diffy strains, act as a reversible conservtv  
system, but must give rise to dissipatn of engy  
in conseq. of the conductn or radiatn of heat  
induced by these changes of temp. 514  
677. Isotropie & Aeolotropie: An individual  
body kann isotrop für gewisse Eigenschaften sein & äolotrop  
für andre: in abstr. dynamics a rigid body or group  
of bodies rigidly connected, contained within &  
rigidly attached to a rigid spherical surface, is  
kinetically symmetrical, if its centre of inertia  
is at the centre of the sphere & if its moments of  
inertia are equal round all diameters. – It is  
also isotropic relve to gravitation if it is Centro-  
baric, so that the C. of figure is [signo: not] merely a centre  
of inertia but a true centre of gravity. –

### Image 16, column 1

Or a transpt{rent}[?] substce may transmit light at difft[?][^20]  
velocities in diffy directns through it (that is, be  
*doubly refracting*) & yet a cube of it may (& does  
generally in natural crystals) absorb the same  
part of a beam of white light transmitted across  
it ppdicly to any of its 3 pairs of faces. Or, as a  
crystal wh exhibits *dichroism*, it may be aeolo-  
tropic relve to the latter, or either qualy & yet  
~~trans~~ it may conduct heat equally in all di-  
rections 578.  
679. Um elastisch isotrop zu sein muß d. Kpr 1) bei allsei-  
tig gleichmäßig applicirtem Druck nur s. Volum [signo: nicht] d. Gestalt  
ändern & 2) bei tangential stress in planes || to {each} two  
pairs of its sides experience simple deformatn  
or shear ohne Contraktn od. Dilatatn. 579.  
686 *Elasticitäts modulus* eingeführt von Th. Young  
= longitudinal rigidity: that is, the quotient ob-  
tained by dividing the simple longitudinal  
force required to produce any infinitesimal  
elongatn or contractn, by the amount of this  
eln or contrn reckoned {at} always pr unit of length.  
Oft, statt in Gewichtseinheit, bequemer in terms  
of the weight of the unit length of the wire, rod  
or thread. The modulus thus reckoned, or as it  
is called by some writers, the length of the  
modulus, is of course obtained by dividing  
the weight-modulus by the weight of unit length.  
Nützlich: z. B. the velocity of transmission of lon-  
gitudinal vibrations (as of sound) along a bar or  
chord, is equal to the velocity acquired by a body in falling  
fm a height = to half the length of the modulus.  
The specific modulus of elastcy of an isotropic  
substce (gewöhnl. bezeichnet als mod. of el. of the subst.)  
is the mod. of elcy of a bar of it having some  
specified sectl. area. If this be such that  
the weight of unit length is unity, the modulus  
of the substce will be the same as the length of the  
modulus of any bar of it. Meist jedoch f. a  
gemeins. Dschnitt gemess.: Grammes Gewicht per  
Quadr. Centimeter: dies dch d. spec. Gewicht dividirt,  
giebt die Länge des Modulus 523.24.  
*Hydrostatik*, oder wie er allge. sagt Hydrodynamik.  
741. By induction from a great variety of observed  
phenomena, we are compelled to conclude that

### Image 16, column 2

no change of volume or of shape can be pro-  
duced in any kind of matter without dissipatn  
of energy; sodaß wenn die frühere Konfiguration  
in e. gegebn Fall wieder hergestellt wird, irgend eine  
wenn auch noch so kleine Arbeitsmenge erforderlich  
ist um die dissipirte Energie zu ersetzen & den Kpr  
in dieselbe physikal. & palpabel. kinet. Lage zu bring.  
von der er ausgegangen worden. Dies Corollar[?] fällt[^21]  
identically with the *absolutely* perfect elastc. of volume  
presented by every fluid & possibly by some solids  
as f. i. homogeneous crystals. But in metals, glass,  
porceln, natl. stones, wd., {homogeneous} jelly, Ind. rubber, silk fibre,  
ivory &c a distinct *frictional resistance* –  
against every change of shape, is ... demonstrd  
by many expermts & is found to depend on the  
speed with wh the change of shape is made ..  
schlagdr Beweis d. Aufhören d. Schwingg elast. fester Kpr, mar-  
vellously rapid in Ind. rubber, & selbst bei Glas &  
Metallfedern viel rascher als d. Luftwiderst. rechtfertigt[?].[^22]  
Dies könne man viscosity of solids nennen 590/91  
A perfect fluid .. is defined as a body incapable  
of resisting change of shape, & therefore incapable  
of experiencing tangentl. or distorting stress. Hence  
its pressure on any surface (ob fest, od. in dr Flüssigkt.  
vorgestellt) is at every point perpdcl to the surface.  
In equilibm all common liquids & gaseous fluids  
fulfil this conditn. But there is a finite resistce,  
of the nature of frictn, opposing change of shape  
at a finite rate; & therefore while a fluid is  
changing shape, it exerts tangentl. force on  
every surface other than normal planes of  
the stress required to keep this change of shape going on.  
Daher d. Hydrostat. Theoret. Resultate praktisch bewährt,  
aber in Hydrokinetik muß in d. meist. Fäll. d. flüssige  
Reibg berücksichtigt werd.  
744. At any point in a fluid at rest the pres-  
sure is the same in all directns, & if no external  
forces act, it is the same at every point. 592.  
Wirken fremde[?] Kräfte ein, so bleibt auf jed. Pkt[^23]  
dr Druck nach allen Richtg gleich, abr ist v. Pkt zu Pkt verschied. 594.  
In ruhend. Flüssigkt sind {Ober}flächen gleich. Drucks  
zugleich Flächen gleicher Dichtigkt & gleichen Potentials. 595.  
Daher, wo ~~[ilegible]~~ Schwere allein wirkt, sind Oberfl. gleicher Dichtigkt  
& gleich. Druckes *horizontale* Fläch., normal dr wirkend  
Kraft. 595.  
Höhe der homogenen Atmosphäre = {imaginär} Höhe der Atmosph.  
bei e. bestimmt. Druck, wenn sie als homogen voraus-  
gesetzt wird. 597.

### Image 17, column 1

*Ebbe & Fluth*. Dreierlei[?]: 1) *halbtägige* Mond- resp.[^24]  
Sonnenfluth, wenig langsam veränderlich; 2) *tägliche*  
Mond- resp. Sonnenfluth, wechselt vom + Max. zum – Max.  
& passirt[?] {[ilegible]} zum + Max., einmal in the tropical period of[^25]  
each body in its orbit; 3) 14tägige Mond- & halbjährige  
Sonnenfluth, wobei there is on the whole higher water all  
round the equator & lower w. at the poles when  
the declinatn of the disturbg body is = 0, &  
max. height at poles & min at eq. when the distur-  
bing body has max declinatn, north or south. 659.  
Dazu noch viele Einfl., Configuratn v. Land & Wasser, Centri-  
fugalkraft d. Erde, Verstärkg dr Wirkg dch gegenseit. Gravitat.  
des gestörtn Wassers.  
825. The phenomena of *precession* & *nutation*  
result from the earth's being not centrobaric  
& therefore attracting the sun & moon (& vice versa)  
in lines wh do not pass precisely thro the earth's  
centre of inertia except when they are in the  
plane of its equator. The attr. of either body  
transferred fm its actl. line to a || line through  
the earth's centre, gives therefore a couple wh, if  
we first assume for simplicity, gravity to  
be symmetrical round the polar axis, tends  
to turn the earth round a diameter of its  
equator, in the direction bringing the plane of  
the equator towards the disturbg body. 682.  
Später soll von Th. & T. bewiesen werdn, dß die  
Verlangsamg dr Erdrotatn dch Fluthreibg d.[?] E to more[^26]  
than a very minute degree aufgewog.[?] dch d. tendency[^27]  
to acceleratn wh results fm secular coolg ~~of~~  
~~the earth~~ & shrinking. 686.  
Ob d. feste Erde a. dr Fluthanziehg nachgiebt? in etwa  
voll[?] [signo: nicht] zu beweisen dß wahrscheinl. dß sie weniger nachgiebt[^28]  
als wenn sie ganz Glas wäre; im letztern Falle würde  
die Meeresfluth nur 2/5 von der f. e. absolut starre  
Körper sein, was doch [signo: nicht] anzunehmen. 699. 700. Jedoch  
dr elast. Nachgeben der Erde geg. d. Attr. Unläugbar, sie  
wolln[?] a. nachweisn dß es f. Präcess. & Nutatn wirkt,[^29]  
& dß höchstwahrsch. d. Präcess., die jetzt äußerst[?] genau fest-[^30]  
gestellt, etwas geringer ist als bei absol. Starrheit dr  
Erde dr Fall sein würde. 702. Daraus folgt dß a.  
innerhalb dr Erde Flüssigkt nur ausnahmsweise vor-  
kommen kann, bei dünner Erdkruste müßte dr Nachgeb.  
viel stärker & daher d. Einstimmg der Präcess. m.[?] dr[^31]  
f. e. absolut starre Erde gegründt. Berechng weit geringer sein 703.

### Image 17, column 2

Aufsatz von W Thomson, on the secular cooling  
of the Earth, *Abdr. a.* Trans. R. S. Edinb 1862.  
Mit Recht geg. d. Übertreibg der Antiparoxystentheori  
die nach Randnote von *Hutton* gegründet, –  
nach denen der jetzige Kräftegrad a. für alle Vergan-  
genheit gültig & alle jetzt [signo: nicht] vorkommd Gewaltänderg  
a. für frühere Perioden[?] Epochen[?].[^32]  
D. Energie d. S.-Systems jetzt viel geringer als vor  
einig. Million Jahr & wahrscheinl. d. Rate der Dissipation  
proptl dem Gesammtvorrath d. Energie, also langsam abneh-  
mend. – D. Sonne vor 1 Mill. Jahren merklich heißer  
als jetzt, & dies darf d. Geologie [signo: nicht] vernachlässigen wie von  
der Quietisten- oder uniformitär[?] Schule geschieht. – sowohl[?][^33]  
die Kataklysmen die zeitweis[?] allem Lebn e. Ende machen[^34]  
zu erwägen wie a. die Gleichmäßigkt[?] der Sonnenwirkg, d.[^35]  
Wärmeabg. für 1 Mill. Jahre. 712  
Schon bei Fourier e. ursprüngl, "*arbitrary* *initial* dis-  
tribution of heat" as it is called in *Fourier's great ma-*  
*thematical poem* angenommen that is to say it cannot  
result from any previous condition of matter  
*by natural processes* .. it could only be real-  
ized by action of a power *able to modify the*  
*laws of dead matter*. 713.  
Da d. Innere dr Erde wärmer, muß sie fort-  
währd dch Leitg & Strahlg Wärme verlieren. Möglich dß  
keine wirkl.[?] [ilegible] Abkühlg entsteht[?], sondern nur e. ex-[^36]  
haustion of potl. energy, wh in this case cd. scarcely  
be other than chemical affinity betw substces  
forming part of the earth's mass .. To suppose as  
Lyell has done, adoptg the chemical hypothesis,  
that the substces, combining together, may be  
again separated electrolytically by thermoelectr.  
currents, due to the heat generated by their  
combinatn, & thus the chemical actn & its heat  
continued in an endless ~~[ilegible]~~ cycle, violates  
the principles of natl. philos. in exactly the same  
manner & to the same degree as to believe that  
a clock constructed with a self-winding move-  
ment may fulfil the expectatn of its ingenious  
inventor by going on for ever. 714  
{also vor 1000 Jahre} So gewiß[?] jetzt wenig vulkan.[?] Energie in d.[^37]  
ganzen Erde) wie etwa[?] in e. Monitor nach 5 Stunden[^38]  
Kampf[?] [ilegible] wenige Munition ist als vorher.[^39]  
Die chem. Theorie sehr schwach, d. Ansicht dß d. Erde einfach  
ihren ursprüngl. Wärmevorrath verliert wahrscheinlich 716.  
Ebenso Poisson's Hypothese die innere Wärme  
sei bei Durchg. d. wärmere Weltregionen aufgenommen  
haltlos. Annahme dß d. Zunahme 1° Fahr. pr 50 Fuß  
sei, brächte[?] d. Region 25 – 50° Fahrenh. über[^40]

### Image 18, column 1

d. jetzige Mitteltemp. der Erdoberfl. heißer gewes  
sein, falls der Durchg {zwisch} 1250 – 5000 Jahre zurück statt-  
gefund{d} was [signo: nicht] d. Fall; noch weniger kann d Geologie  
zugeb. dß vor 20,000 J. d. Erde dch e 100° Fahr. wär-  
mer Region passirt sei; noch weiter zurückverlegt, muß  
d. regionale Wärmeüberschuß mehr als 100° F. betrag  
[ilegible] [ilegible] vermittelt[?] habe.[^41]  
Am einfachst *Leibnitz's* Hypoth. die Erde sei einst  
a incandescent liquid gewes ohne zu sag wie &  
wo? & erst später in a Consistentior status gekomm  
der Leb. mögl. machte & d. initial date of all geolog  
history bildet. – Wenn Felsen bei 10,000° F. schmelzen  
kann d Consolidg {vor} ca 200,000,000 J., wenn wie gewöhnl. an-  
genomm bei 7000° F., vor 98,000 J. stattgefund hab.  
Diese Annahme f. Fourier's Lösg dr Wärmeleitg{&c}[?] gegründ[^42]  
Um ganz sicher zu gehn nimmt Th an dß d. Cons. stattgefund  
hab muß zwisch 20 – 400 Mill Jahren *verladen*. 716.  
Mathemat. Untersuchg[?] gestützt f. Fourier – wirft Licht f.[^43]  
d Frage ob d. Klima dch Erdwärmeausstrahlg wärmer  
gemacht werd können? *Nein*. 10,000 J. nach Anfg der  
Abkühlg würde d. Temp. at the rate of 2° F. pr foot  
downwards wachs., also d. Oberfl. Temp. um schwerl.  
mehr als 1° erhöhen[?]. Also fast ohne Wirkg; d. E.wärme[^44]  
[ilegible]{d} Lavabrüche lokal d. Temp. erhöhen, ohne[?] d.[^45]  
ersten 3 – 4 Mill J. würd d. Pflanzenwuchs[?] ± von d.[^46]  
innern Wärme profitirt. 720.  
Was d. Betrag dr Wirkg{d} sein möge zu irgd e.  
Zeit, er würde abnehm. im umgek. Verhältn. dr Quadr-  
wurzeln dr Zeit: nach 40,000 J. – 1° pr Fuß, nach  
160,000 J – 1/2° pr Fuß, 4 Mill J. – 1/10, 100 Mill J.  
1/50° pr Fuß. Danach würde in d letzt 96,000,000  
J. die Wärmesteigerungsrate von 1/10° f 1/50° pr Fuß ge-  
sunk & die Dicke dr Erdkruste von 1/5 auf 1 gewach-  
sen. Damit stimmt d Geologie: the vast masses of  
basalt, the genl. appearance of mountain ranges, the  
violent distorts & fract.s of strata, *the great prevalence*  
*of metamorphic actn* (wh must have taken  
place at depths of not many miles if so much) 721.  
A large mass of melted rock, freely exposed  
to our air & sky, will, after it once becomes crusted  
over, present in a few hours, or a few days, or at  
most a few weeks, a surface so cool that it can  
be walked over with impunity. Von d. Erde also nach  
10,000 J. oder selbst 1 Jahr, dasselbe anzunehm. 721.  
Schlußf{d}[?]: Erdkruste wie Eis[?], bildet[?], bricht, & decay[^47]

### Image 18, column 2

Bischof's erstarrender Fels s. um Ca. 20 %[?] zus.[?] zieht,[^48]  
{4.} zum Centr. sinkt & so a honeycombed crust im  
Innern bildet, d. flüssigste[?] mehr nach ob. fließt[^49]  
& allmählig *dort erstarrt*.

[^1]: Uncertain reading: ausdehnende[?]; alternatives: Schmierende.

[^2]: Uncertain reading: lergränze[?] m.[?]; alternatives: lergränzen; mit.

[^3]: Uncertain reading: Felsen[?]; alternatives: Felsblöcke.

[^4]: Uncertain reading: Schwere[?]; alternatives: irdische.

[^5]: Uncertain reading: {(inwendig[?])!}; alternatives: inward.

[^6]: Uncertain reading: &c.[?]; alternatives: e. g..

[^7]: Uncertain reading: see[?]; alternatives: (ninguna).

[^8]: Uncertain reading: {[ilegible]}; alternatives: (ninguna).

[^9]: Uncertain reading: Green[?] Behauptg[?]; alternatives: Grund, Begriff.

[^10]: Uncertain reading: {P}[?]; alternatives: (ninguna).

[^11]: Uncertain reading: m.[?]; alternatives: mit.

[^12]: Uncertain reading: m.[?]; alternatives: mit.

[^13]: Uncertain reading: Ext.[?]; alternatives: Ungl..

[^14]: Uncertain reading: v.[?] unendl.[?]; alternatives: d. Entferng.

[^15]: Uncertain reading: dritter[?]; alternatives: drittes.

[^16]: Uncertain reading: ganz[?] allg.[?]; alternatives: [ilegible].

[^17]: Uncertain reading: aus[?]; alternatives: statt.

[^18]: Uncertain reading: diese[?]; alternatives: sie.

[^19]: Uncertain reading: vollelast.[?]; alternatives: [ilegible].

[^20]: Uncertain reading: transpt{rent}[?] difft[?]; alternatives: transparent; diffl.

[^21]: Uncertain reading: Corollar[?]; alternatives: Corrolar.

[^22]: Uncertain reading: rechtfertigt[?]; alternatives: verursacht.

[^23]: Uncertain reading: fremde[?]; alternatives: [ilegible].

[^24]: Uncertain reading: Dreierlei[?]; alternatives: Ursachen dreifach; Verschiedne Arten.

[^25]: Uncertain reading: passirt[?] {[ilegible]}; alternatives: zurück.

[^26]: Uncertain reading: d.[?]; alternatives: bis.

[^27]: Uncertain reading: aufgewog.[?]; alternatives: [ilegible].

[^28]: Uncertain reading: voll[?]; alternatives: rohe; wohl.

[^29]: Uncertain reading: wolln[?]; alternatives: volle.

[^30]: Uncertain reading: äußerst[?]; alternatives: fast.

[^31]: Uncertain reading: m.[?]; alternatives: & der.

[^32]: Uncertain reading: Perioden[?] Epochen[?]; alternatives: Grund.

[^33]: Uncertain reading: uniformitär[?] sowohl[?]; alternatives: uniformitarian.

[^34]: Uncertain reading: zeitweis[?]; alternatives: zwischen.

[^35]: Uncertain reading: Gleichmäßigkt[?]; alternatives: Schwankungen.

[^36]: Uncertain reading: wirkl.[?] [ilegible] entsteht[?]; alternatives: volle neue; statt findet.

[^37]: Uncertain reading: gewiß[?] vulkan.[?]; alternatives: Dagegen; spontane; potentielle.

[^38]: Uncertain reading: etwa[?]; alternatives: daß.

[^39]: Uncertain reading: Kampf[?] [ilegible]; alternatives: weniger.

[^40]: Uncertain reading: brächte[?]; alternatives: bringt.

[^41]: Uncertain reading: [ilegible] [ilegible] vermittelt[?]; alternatives: abgeleitet; abnormal hohe.

[^42]: Uncertain reading: Wärmeleitg{&c}[?]; alternatives: {sPr}.

[^43]: Uncertain reading: Untersuchg[?]; alternatives: Beweis; Untersuchgsresultat.

[^44]: Uncertain reading: erhöhen[?]; alternatives: erhöht.

[^45]: Uncertain reading: [ilegible]{d} ohne[?]; alternatives: durch; gänzl.; aber.

[^46]: Uncertain reading: Pflanzenwuchs[?]; alternatives: Pflanzenwesen.

[^47]: Uncertain reading: Schlußf{d}[?] Eis[?] bildet[?]; alternatives: Schluß; ein; lichtet.

[^48]: Uncertain reading: %[?] zus.[?]; alternatives: proz.; Fuß.

[^49]: Uncertain reading: flüssigste[?]; alternatives: flüssiges.
